Global reproductive and women's rights groups react to overturn of Roe v. Wade
How will the overturn of Roe v. Wade affect abortion rights and access outside the U.S.?
Groups that are opposed to abortion have welcomed the decision, including the Family Resource Council, which has called it "a major victory for life." But many global reproductive and women's rights groups are condemning the decision and warn that the U.S. overturning of the constitutional right to abortion will have far-reaching effects around the globe.
Here's a sampling of reactions:
'More unsafe abortions will occur around the world'
In a statement, UNFPA, the United Nations' sexual and reproductive health agency, reminds the public that 45% of the world's abortions are unsafe — and a leading cause of maternal death. The agency, which supports reproductive health care for women and youth in more than 150 countries, believes that the U.S. Supreme Court decision may spur other countries to follow suit:
"Almost all unsafe abortions currently occur in developing countries, and UNFPA fears that more unsafe abortions will occur around the world if access to abortion becomes more restricted. Decisions reversing progress gained have a wider impact on the rights and choices of women and adolescents everywhere."
'One of the leading causes of preventable maternal death'
FIGO, the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics, released a statement that, like the UNFPA comment, underscores the toll of unsafe abortions:
"Lack of access to safe abortion care is one of the leading causes of preventable maternal death and disability. Each year, 47,000 women in the world die as a result of unsafe abortion and an estimated 5 million are hospitalized for the treatment of serious complications such as bleeding or infection."
More than 100 global health-care groups in countries from Azerbaijan to Zimbabwe signed on to the statement.
'This vote may embolden the anti-choice movement'
Sarah Shaw, global head of advocacy for MSI Reproductive Choices, a group that provides contraception and safe abortion services in 37 countries, issued a statement describing ways the decision may stymie abortion access abroad, raising the example of past U.S. bans on funding international groups that discuss abortion with patients. (Reproductive rights groups often refer to these bans as the "Global Gag Rule.')
"As a global abortion provider, we know that the impact of this decision will also be felt around the world. From the Global GagRule to U.S.-funded anti-choice groups who harass women outside our clinics and lobby governments to restrict access, decisions made in the U.S. have an impact far beyond their borders."
Shaw also sounded a note of resistance: "But while this vote may embolden the anti-choice movement around the world, it has also motivated the global community to reassert the right to choose."
'Banning abortion does not mean fewer abortions'
Dr. Alvaro Bermejo, director-general of the International Planned Parenthood Federation, said his group, which provides safe abortion, contraceptives, sex education and maternal care among other health needs in over 146 countries, does not believe the Supreme Court decision will lead to a reduction in the number of abortions.
"We know for a fact that banning abortion does not mean fewer abortions and that when abortion bans are enacted, women and pregnant people die, as we have seen across the globe, most recently in Poland [where a near-total ban on abortion took effect in 2021]. We also know that those who cannot access safe abortion care legally, including medical abortion pills, will be forced into unregulated and unsafe methods, potentially resulting in serious harm or even death and costing lives for decades to come."
'Only Poland, El Salvador and Nicaragua have enacted more restrictive laws'
Nabeeha Kazi Hutchins, president and CEO of PAI, an international sexual and reproductive health and rights advocacy organization, said in a statement that the U.S. is moving in a direction that is contrary to most other countries.
"Since the 1990s, over 60 countries have liberalized laws for sexual and reproductive health and rights, and many have moved toward the decriminalization of abortion. ... Only Poland, El Salvador and Nicaragua have enacted more restrictive laws since then. Now, heartbreakingly, the United States has joined them."
'Women, pregnant people and providers will go to jail'
Anu Kumar, president and CEO of Ipas, an international group that works to expand access to abortion worldwide, said in a statement that doctors offering abortion and people seeking abortion will be more likely to face criminal charges.
"In Brazil, we've seen police raids of abortion clinics, and in Nicaragua we've seen doctors stop providing lifesaving treatment because they're scared of arrest. In places like El Salvador, and in the past in Nepal and Rwanda, women have been put in jail when abortion is criminalized."
'Abortion bans ... are violent embodiments of systemic racism'
Global Fund for Women, a group that funds gender justice movements around the world, warned in a news release that the ruling will be especially harmful to people of color and people from low-income backgrounds.
"Abortion bans are designed to constrict people's control over their bodies, lives and futures. They disproportionately harm historically marginalized people, including Black, Indigenous and low-income communities. Legislative restrictions on bodily autonomy — including abortion bans, anti-trans policies, and constraints on gender-affirming health care — are violent embodiments of systemic racism, sexism and oppression."
'All hope is not lost'
Dr. Milly Nanyombi Kaggwa, senior clinical advisor for Africa at Population Services International, a global nonprofit group that works to provide sexual and reproductive health care in 50 countries, reminded that abortion is still available in the vast majority of the world, according to an email statement to NPR.
"The effects of restricting or banning abortions in many U.S. states are dire – but as the Global South's experience underscores: all hope is not lost."
"Abortion in sub-Saharan Africa, like in the U.S., isn't illegal everywhere. Globally, abortion is only prohibited in 5% of countries. While that is unacceptable for the estimated 90 million women of reproductive age who live in those countries, this also means that in 95% of countries, abortion is legal for some circumstances. It's critical that people – health consumers and providers alike – understand what their rights and options are."
Copyright 2022 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.